Gig & Side IncomeAdvanced6 min read

Hiring your first helper: subcontractors, 1099s, and payroll

Scaling a gig means bringing in help — and the contractor-versus-employee line carries real tax and legal weight. What each choice obligates you to do.

A successful gig eventually outgrows one person. The house cleaner with more bookings than hours, the handyman turning down jobs, the freelancer with more work than capacity — all eventually consider hiring help. The moment you do, you cross into employer territory, and the first decision, contractor versus employee, determines a cascade of tax and legal obligations you cannot afford to get wrong.

Contractor or employee? The distinction that matters

The classification hinges mainly on control: how much you direct the way the work is done, not just the result. A true independent contractor controls their own methods, hours, and tools and typically works for others too. An employee works under your direction, on your schedule, with your tools. The more control you exert, the more likely the law treats the person as an employee — regardless of what you call them.

Misclassification is an expensive mistake

Labeling someone a contractor to dodge payroll taxes when they function as an employee is a serious, well-enforced error. If challenged, you can owe back employment taxes, the worker’s share you failed to withhold, plus penalties and interest — and state agencies pursue this aggressively. When the relationship looks like employment, treat it as employment.

If you hire a contractor

Collect a completed Form W-9 before you pay them, capturing their taxpayer ID.
Issue a Form 1099-NEC if you pay them the reporting threshold or more in a year.
Keep records of what you paid and the business purpose.
Remember you do not withhold taxes or pay payroll tax on a genuine contractor.

If you hire an employee

Get an EIN and register with federal and state tax agencies.
Run formal payroll, withholding income and payroll taxes from each check.
Pay the employer share of Social Security and Medicare, plus unemployment taxes.
Carry workers’ compensation insurance where required, and follow labor laws.

Obligation	Contractor	Employee
Tax withholding	None	Required
Payroll taxes	None	Employer share owed
Year-end form	1099-NEC	W-2
Workers’ comp	Generally no	Often required
Control over work	Worker controls methods	You direct the work

Contractor vs. employee: your obligations

Start with contractors for variable work

For occasional overflow or specialized tasks, a genuine independent contractor is simpler and lighter to administer. Reserve employee status for ongoing, controlled roles where you direct the day-to-day. Just make sure the reality of the relationship matches the label — a "contractor" you schedule, supervise, and equip like staff is an employee in the eyes of the law.

The bottom line: hiring help turns you into an employer with real obligations, and the contractor-versus-employee call drives everything downstream — withholding, payroll taxes, forms, and insurance. Classify by the substance of the relationship, not the convenience of the label, use W-9s and 1099-NECs for genuine contractors, and stand up proper payroll for employees. Because misclassification penalties are steep, confirm your setup with a CPA or employment attorney before you make the first hire.

Check your understanding

1 of 3

What mainly determines whether a worker is a contractor or an employee?

Not quite — try again.

The Worth letter

Get smarter about money every week

One email, no spam — practical guides and Worth updates. Unsubscribe anytime.

Put this into practice

Worth tracks your accounts, budgets, and goals — so the concepts in this article aren't just theory.

Start free trial